Thus, political uncertainty appears to be conspicuous by its
absence so far as markets are concerned, which reflects the fact that investors
are looking through all the rhetoric and concluding that the likelihood of a
cliff-edge Brexit is low. Since we are still more than 16 months away from the
expiry of the Article 50 negotiation phase, markets take the view that there is
no sense in panicking now – there will be plenty of time for that later.
Nonetheless, the closer we get to the deadline without agreement, the greater
the likelihood that assets will come under pressure, but that is probably a story
for next year.
The chart suggests that the aggregate uncertainty index has
dipped back close to its long-term average (2000-2015). Whilst the domestic
indicator has not fallen quite as sharply, it is well below its summer 2016
highs with only the Baker et al policy uncertainty index showing any extended
deviation. The interesting thing is that this policy uncertainty index is based
on an online trawl of newspaper websites looking for various keywords which express
uncertainty. To the extent that much of the concern expressed about Brexit has
indeed come via the media (not to mention the blogosphere, so I am as guilty as
anyone), it highlights the noise inherent in the debate without necessarily
shedding much light on how the economy is performing. Indeed, many of the other
indicators normalised very quickly, which suggests that most economic agents
generally got on with life in the wake of the Brexit vote.
This does not mean to say that everything will remain so quiet. The GfK survey data point to a deterioration in expectations for the future economic situation with sentiment now back at levels last seen in spring 2013. Moreover, with inflation beginning to put the squeeze on consumers, we are starting to see some deterioration in expectations for consumer finances.
It is worth noting that the indicator is not a good predictor of longer-term trends. Even in the early months of 2008, when there were signs that trouble was brewing in the banking sector and the economy was losing some momentum, both the aggregate and domestic uncertainty indices remained at low levels. A lurch towards the cliff-edge of Brexit could change perceptions quite markedly. Perhaps UK consumers and corporates need to hurt even more before they realise the potential economic consequences of Brexit. This is why just looking at the current relative stability of the uncertainty index is not necessarily a good guide to future trends. In my view – and that of most of the economics profession – a number of senior British politicians do not seem to understand the risk they are taking with the wider economy. It is incumbent upon them to get it right or the electorate may be in a less forgiving mood than it has been of late.
This does not mean to say that everything will remain so quiet. The GfK survey data point to a deterioration in expectations for the future economic situation with sentiment now back at levels last seen in spring 2013. Moreover, with inflation beginning to put the squeeze on consumers, we are starting to see some deterioration in expectations for consumer finances.
It is worth noting that the indicator is not a good predictor of longer-term trends. Even in the early months of 2008, when there were signs that trouble was brewing in the banking sector and the economy was losing some momentum, both the aggregate and domestic uncertainty indices remained at low levels. A lurch towards the cliff-edge of Brexit could change perceptions quite markedly. Perhaps UK consumers and corporates need to hurt even more before they realise the potential economic consequences of Brexit. This is why just looking at the current relative stability of the uncertainty index is not necessarily a good guide to future trends. In my view – and that of most of the economics profession – a number of senior British politicians do not seem to understand the risk they are taking with the wider economy. It is incumbent upon them to get it right or the electorate may be in a less forgiving mood than it has been of late.
No comments:
Post a Comment